Index Funds vs. Mutual Funds: Which One Should You Choose?

Among the most common decisions investors face is whether to place their money in mutual funds or index funds.

Insights and blogs

Nov 04, 2025

Two popular options you’ll hear about in investing are index funds and mutual funds. While both offer ways to grow your money by pooling investments, they work quite differently. The key differences that can affect costs, performance, and long-term suitability.

When you compare index funds vs. mutual funds, the decision should be based on your financial goals, your comfort with management style, and your expectations about fees.

What Are Index Funds

An index fund is a type of mutual fund that takes a different approach. Instead of trying to beat the market, it simply tracks the performance of a chosen index. For example, if the fund is tied to the PSEi, it buys the same stocks in the same proportions as the index.

This is called passive investing . There is no constant buying or selling based on a fund manager’s judgment. Instead, the fund aims to match the index’s performance rather than outperform it. This structure is why index funds often have lower fees compared to actively managed funds.

What Are Mutual Funds

A mutual fund is a pool of money collected from many investors and managed by a professional fund manager who makes active decisions on which securities to buy and sell. The goal is usually to outperform a benchmark index, such as the Philippine Stock Exchange index or the S&P 500 abroad.

Mutual funds come in different types:

Equity Funds (Stock Funds). These funds mainly invest in stocks or shares of companies. They are designed for investors who want the chance to grow their money over time. Equity funds are best if you have a long-term goal and can handle ups and downs in the market.
Bond Funds (Fixed Income Funds). Bond funds invest in loans or bonds issued by governments or companies. They tend to be less risky than stocks, offering more stable but generally lower returns. These funds are suitable if you want a steady income and want to protect your capital.
Balanced Funds (Hybrid Funds). Balanced funds combine both stocks and bonds to give investors a mix of growth and income. They aim to reduce risk through diversification, making them suitable for investors looking for moderate growth with lower volatility.
Money Market Funds. Money market funds are short-term, low-risk debt instruments that will give a better yield than regular savings accounts. These include treasury bills and certificates of deposit.

Difference Between Index Funds and Mutual Funds

First-time investors often ask, “Should I invest in mutual funds or index funds?” Your choice will depend on various factors:

1. Management Style

Index funds follow a passive management style. They aim to replicate a specific market index by holding the same stocks or bonds in the same proportions. No active trading or research is involved, keeping it simple and predictable.

On the other hand, mutual funds are mostly actively managed by fund managers who analyze and choose investments aiming to beat the market. Managers make buying and selling decisions regularly, which adds a dynamic but less predictable approach to the fund.

2. Investment Goals

Index funds aim to closely match the performance of a benchmark index. Their goal is stable market returns over time. Mutual funds, however, seek to outperform a benchmark through expert stock or bond selection. This often means trying to achieve higher returns than the overall market, but with greater uncertainty.

3. Costs

In the Philippines, index funds typically have higher management fees than the global average. For example, the BPI Philippine Equity Index Fund charges a trust fee of 1.50% per annum, and the Philippine Stock Index Fund charges a management and advisory fee of around 1.00% per annum. Mutual funds also have fees that can range around 1% to 1.5% or more.

4. Performance

Index funds deliver returns closely aligned to their benchmark, offering predictable long-term growth. Mutual funds have the potential for higher returns but with greater variability; success depends on the skill and decisions of the fund manager.

5. Risk

Index funds track the overall market, so their value moves with the index they follow, which means that investors face the same market fluctuations. Mutual funds, however, rely on the decisions of their fund managers. These choices can help reduce risk, but can also increase it if the manager’s picks don’t do well.

6. Suitability for Investors

Index funds are ideal for those who want a simple, low-cost way to invest in steady market returns. They’re great for beginners or anyone who prefers a hands-off approach.

Meanwhile, mutual funds are suited for investors who don’t mind paying higher fees and taking on more risk for the chance to earn higher returns through active management. These investors accept that returns may be more unpredictable.

Index Funds or Mutual Funds: Finding Your Balance

Mutual funds or index funds? There is no single answer, as each option has its strengths. Some investors even hold both, diversifying their portfolios with a mix of passive and active strategies. This allows them to enjoy the cost-efficiency and stability of index funds while still tapping into the potential for higher returns through actively managed mutual funds.

It’s a smart way to diversify—not just across asset classes, but also in investment styles.

If you want to explore both, there is a wide range of investment funds tailored to different risk appetites and financial goals. With professional guidance and flexible options, it's easier than ever to invest with confidence.

The Key to Success: Consistency Over Timing

In the debate over index funds vs. mutual funds, investors often focus on market timing. The truth is, consistency matters more. Whether you invest in index funds or mutual funds, regular contributions build wealth over time. Market fluctuations are less critical when you invest steadily and allow compounding to work in your favor.

Start Your Investment Journey with Clarity

The decision between mutual funds vs. index funds should hinge on your management style, goals, costs, performance, risk, and suitability. Index funds are usually better for long-term, cost-conscious investors who want reliable returns that match the market. Mutual funds are often suited to those who want active management and are willing to accept additional costs for the potential of outperformance.

Whichever you choose, investing consistently and wisely is what ultimately grows your wealth. Now is the perfect time to start or review your investment strategy with confidence.

Discover More Banking and Financial Tips